College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

Japanese anime destroying American society

In My Opinion | Instant Gratification

By Elon Glucklich

|

Published: Monday, October 15, 2007

Updated: Wednesday, July 29, 2009

It wasn't until around the fifth grade that I began to think something was wrong. That year, a strange new cartoon worked its way into the social lexicon of coolness. It was called "Dragon Ball Z" and, for reasons my 10-year-old mind could not articulate, it was making me nervous. Ten years later, I can't help thinking that I could have done something, anything, to stop the tsunami of anime that was to come.

In a society dominated by excess and two-second attention spans, cartoons play a significant role in preparing us for the world. Each can be thought of as a 30-minute babysitter, instilling the kids who watch them with certain values and life lessons. But the landscape has changed.

Before I go any further, I should state the following: No matter who you are - whether you're black, white, Asian, Latino, even Canadian - I don't judge you by the color of your skin. I say this because I direct my comments to the media elites, in Japan and elsewhere, who have taken it upon themselves to flood the airwaves with shows like "Pokemon," "Digimon," and "Yugio" - sorry, "Yu-Gi-Oh!" They all started as card trading games, and should have ended there as well. Instead they've jumped to the mass media, where they're slowly chipping away at our collective moral fiber.

It's not a conspiracy. A conspiracy, by definition, requires that multiple parties are working together to achieve some sort of goal. None of the shows I've seen make nearly enough sense to be working toward anything other than a lackluster battle between Bulbasaur and Charmander and the next commercial break.

Don't believe the threat's real? A report from CNN's Tokyo affiliate in December 1997 documented an incident in which "More than 700 people, mainly school children, were rushed to hospitals Tuesday after suffering convulsions, vomiting, irritated eyes and other symptoms." Was it a gas leak at the local school? No. Were the kids breathing glue out of brown paper bags? No. Were they watching "Pokemon"? You bet your authentic Squirtle trading card they were.

Remember the cartoons you watched as a child, like "Rugrats"? Everyone watched "Rugrats." With his toothless grin and indomitable spirit, Tommy Pickles represented the very best in all of us. He was like a Che Guevara for the MTV generation. Sure, when he and the rest of the Rugrats "grew up" I died a little inside. But still, not a day goes by where I don't take a moment and thank Tommy for the life lessons he taught me. So what is Pokemon teaching the next generation of kids? The virtues of capturing exotic animals and making them fight for your amusement? I already learned that from Michael Vick.

Some of you may be thinking, "That's all well and good, but what about all of the mindless American television?" After all, this country invented mindless television. And networks like VH1 are keeping that proud tradition alive. But the difference here lies in the target audience: Shows like "Flavor of Love" and "Hogan Knows Best" are watched by people who have already been stupid for years, even decades. There's nothing we can do but make them as comfortable as possible.

The next generations of kids aren't even getting a chance. Unless something is done to reverse this trend, we're going to be looking at millions of high school dropouts who don't see the point in going to college unless it teaches them to capture magic crystals. No one wants to see that day. This issue transcends politics, even religion. It's the ethical dilemma of our day and age, one that makes me want to throw my hands in the air, and yell, "Will someone think of the children?"

eglucklich@dailyemerald.com

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

24 comments

Anonymous
Wed Feb 3 2010 13:10
Well, I can't get too upset.

One of the conditions the U.S. put on France to receive aid under the Marshall Plan was that they lift the limit on the number of U.S. movies allowed in the country each year. The result was that Hollywood dominated France through the 1950s.

In England, the same thing. American youth culture dominated. Teenagers were wearing jeans, drinking Coca-Cola, listening to rock and roll, hanging around in milk bars.

Of course, when the '60s rolled around it all came back on us. With music, there was the British Invasion. In movies, there was the French New Wave from which it took Hollywood years to recover.

I heard someone explain the success of Pokemon. Children like cute animals. And children like fighting. Pokemon combined the two.

Anonymous
Tue Feb 2 2010 16:51
Hello. I'm sure that you may have received many e-mails from upset Anime fans. I just so happen to be a fan of Anime. However I am only writing you to tell you that if your goal is to one day become journalist, and by journalist I mean a real news reporter not someone who works for The Inquirer or some BS like that, then you should learn to check your facts. You kept refering to the more childish anime series which in most episodes have the same recurring theme, Friendship, Loyalty, and Love. That is not a bad thing and it is not destroying our society. Most of the better Anime shows actually make you think and look for the deeper meaning behind the plot. That is something American cartoons definately do not do. American cartoons are either completely pointless or in a small yet obvious way do teach a lesson yet doesn't cause you to actually think and use your brain. Before you try writing about something it really would be best if you check to see if what you are saying is true. All these people are getting upset over this and neglecting the fact that under the title of this little article it says "In My Opinion" So this article really was just your opinion but that may have been more apparent if you had written "in my opinion", or "I think..." things to show that throughout the piece it was just your opinion and it wasn't you trying to say that this is a completely true article.lol Have a nice day.
Yu-Gi-Oh says
Mon Feb 1 2010 15:42
For those recent comments, this piece is meant to be satirical...relax
Anonymous
Sun Jan 31 2010 08:13
Way to patronise kids by deciding they can't choose their own forms of entertainment.

Anime/manga are there to be enjoyed, not to instill moral values in those who watch them.

Anonymous
Sun Jan 31 2010 06:39
You said "who have taken it upon themselves to flood the airwaves with shows like "Pokemon," "Digimon," and "Yugio" - sorry, "Yu-Gi-Oh!" They all started as card trading games, and should have ended there as well."

I just wanted to let you know that they were Anime/Manga LONG BEFORE they were ever card games.

Anonymous
Sun Jan 31 2010 06:30
Wow. This is xenophobic at best. If you didn't fire this ugly cretin of a writer, then consider your stupid little university paper as important as those National Inquirers. I take that back, then consider your stupid ass university itself as a cesspool of American Society.
Please tell me how my life was ruined by anime
Thu Jan 28 2010 10:13
I grew up watching anime, I love Pokemon. I rarely get anything lower than b's on my report cards (I am 15), and I plan to go to college. I still watch anime, and it constantly reminds me of my morals. Pokemon shows friendship and loyalty, as do many other anime shows. Besides, the really pointless ones are supposed to be just for adults, they were only shown on Adult Swim, although the majority of the shows there are American. I'm probably being a little biased, but hey, I'm admitting it. Sure, I also watched some Rugrats, but Tommy didn't really show me much, other than reminding me that a child that young couldn't possibly talk that well or know how to do that much stuff. Sorry.
LeChatNoir
Wed Jan 13 2010 15:05
Wow, blaming society's problems on a genre of animation is pretty down right idiotic. I watched pokemon and digimon growing up, and I now attend a well known university, got scholarships to go there, I graduated with a 3.9 from high school too by the way, and so did my best friend who also watched these shows. If you were not so biased against anime, then you would have realized that the reason why these people fell ill, was because the flashing lights gave some people seizures, which they later corrected that issue. Your assumptions are just asinine and weak, find a new hobby please.
xg
Sun Jan 10 2010 23:35
So all those shows on the Disney channel about dumb pre-teen antics that seem to exist to promote bland look-alike pop starlets -- are those teaching important life lessons, or are they aimed at adults? Or don't they exist? What about those shows like Transformers and GI Joe back in the '80s that were made purely to sell toys?

Yeah, maybe I'm just offended because I did watch Pokemon growing up (and graduated college with honors at the age of twenty, thank you very much). But honestly, you can't claim that Japan has the monopoly on inane children's programming, nor can you dismiss the entertainment industry of an entire country based on the shows it makes to sell stuff to eight-year-olds.

Girl Who Has A Future BECAUSE Of Anime
Mon Dec 28 2009 19:12
Wow, that was a horrible argument...no offense....I've been watching Anime since I was like 10 and I am now 18 and nothing bad has come out of it. In fact, most of the effects have been good influences on my life. It has given me a job interest that includes a 4 year college, inumerable amounts of friends around the globe, an interest in the cultures around me, AND it was the thing that GAVE me a FUTURE to look forward to. I agree with many of these other comments...Anime, unlike a lot of American cartoons, promotes hard-work, the determination to chase your dreams, and loving friendships. I believe I'm accurate in saying that all anime fans, young and old, take more interest in the story behind all the fighting. For example, a girl lost her leg in an accident and watched Fullmetal Alchemist, an equally violent show, and was given the inspiration and determination to walk again after connecting with the main character who also lost his leg. (Don't believe that? Look it up. I heard it first hand...)
And about that whole college comment...What the hell!? Now that just pisses me off!!!! You think kids who watch anime don't want to learn or have a job because of anime!!!? Well I, along with all my friends, were inspired BY ANIME to go to college and do what we love! In fact, there are hundreds of fans who were inspired by anime to become actors or animators or authors or teachers or even Japanese Missionaries. I for one have been tremendously inspired by a CHRISTIAN voice actor named Vic Mignogna who takes tremendous pride in knowing that his work in anime is sparking the creativity of the youth. His work has inspired me to write and draw and someday animate my creations. How is that bad!?
Sorry to break it to you buddy, but Anime is better for the younger generation's morals than American cartoons in soooooooooooo many ways. Unlike it's American counterpart, Anime has deep, rich stories that are usually meant to go AGAINST violence and FOR protecting those you love. Compared to shows like even the Looney Toons, which is pointless and pure violence, Anime has that deep meaning and well-composed story that sucks you in and actually teaches you something.
Anime inspires and helps people, it doesn't destory the lives of children.
Next time....do your research man....
LONG LIVE ANIME!!!!!
Your name
Wed Nov 25 2009 23:59
Ive watched anime all my life (pretty much) and i beleive that i have more morals than some of my classmates there is nothing wrong with anime. Your just overimaganitive, the reason kids act the way they do is not the televisions fault or the enviroment its the parents who dont take responsibility for their childrens wellbeing. If you dont beleive me im fourteen and i beleive i have more common since then people three times my age. Go find some kids about 14 and ask if they want to join the army and if they say yes ask them why, i think you will be shocked at what they say.
TheFirstForgottenSoul
Mon Nov 23 2009 15:02
As a producer, I of course am not opposed to the viewing of anime, I promote it. Having said that, my opinion on the matter is biased. However, one can not ignore the fact that Anime is just as much at fault as American cartoons are. In fact, American cartoons are worse because of the fact that they can be accessed by anyone with basic television channels.

On Nickelodeon, there is a show called iCarly. This show is about a young girl and her friends doing a webshow. They have people half naked, floating bras, and there are numerous references that take a little thought to get, but the mature references are still there. The popular cartoon character “Spongebob” constantly gets in trouble, even provoking some characters into nearly attempting suicide (check Dunces and Dragons for this reference).

No matter their content, American cartoons and Anime both have messages beyond all of the fighting, the humor, and the drama. The messages for Anime can be to find strength to fight no matter what, or to always chase your dreams, or that you must not act rashly as to not hurt your loved ones.

One anime, Tsubasa Resevoir Chronicles, promotes the importance of memories, as well as showing the value of friendship, love, loyalty, and bravery. A young girl named Sakura loses her memories, which are scattered across various worlds. Three heroes paths cross, and they join together to help Sakura obtain her memories again. These memories are materialized as feathers, which hold great power. People abuse this power, and that is what these hereos try to stop. Many different lessons are learned, varying depending on the situation.

If someone is to say that there is absolutely no meaning behind an Anime, they are probably wrong. Even when there is no obvious meaning, often an Anime show’s purpose is to just get the viewer thinking about the plot, which actually helps in the development of the viewer’s intelligence. American shows like Monk do this as well.

So no matter where you look, you will find meaning in both. There are many with an automatic bias against anime because of the fact that it is Japanese. The interesting thing is that the Japanese recieved inspiration from American cartoons like Snow White, and from this, they created Anime. So American cartoons essentially gave birth to Anime, making them equally at fault.

AND about this "next generation" bit. The previous generation, by your standards, was infected by Tom and Jerry, and other such cartoons. They had no point to them, just violence and completely ignoring the laws of physics. They didn't even try to be close to reality. If what you said is true, those shows would be even more harmful than the worst Anime, for most Anime at least has a meaning within one episode. Yet, I do not believe those shows were harmful. Anime is not either.

ALSO: Canadian is a nationality, not a race. There isn't a color of skin generall associated with Canadians except White.

Anyone who sees this, contact me if you would like to speak more about this subject. Perhaps if someone is to speak truthfully to this person, without allowing themselves to freak out, maybe this person can be persuaded to think differently.

thefirstforgottensoul@yahoo.com

i kid
Mon Nov 2 2009 19:28
"someone who did his research" is right, none of them started off as tv shows. hah.
my mistake.
Anime Nerd's Little Sister
Mon Nov 2 2009 19:23
And so, I'm not into anime either, except for hayao miyazaki movies, and my older brother is an anime nerd but just for the record; pokemon etc. did not start off as trading cards. they were animations. cartoons. on tv.
Su Donim
Sun Nov 1 2009 09:33
I have been watching Japanese anime for a long time, since fourth grade, and I am 21 years of age now, and I do learn a lot of good life lessons from them. Take the movie "AIR," for example. It shows that you cannot always save the ones you love. Another life lesson I already knew was reinforced by the anime came from "Tweeny Witches." Did you ever stop to think that sometimes the small things are important to you too? I strongly suggest that you pick up the TV series "Kino's Journey." It is the most spiritually moving series I have ever seen. The story takes it up to eleven when it comes to why we do things, why we think certain ways and the very structure of society. I could go on with my list of good advise from anime, but it would take hours. If you have children, I would reccomend watching "Kodocha" with them. It's a family show about an elementary school girl who is a full time TV idol. I have never seen a show promote friendship quite the way they did, but it still worked. Also, Canadian is a nationality. not a race.
313
Thu Oct 22 2009 19:33
I cosign with Pho-Yuck this article is xenophobic. You should really do more research before you speak on things.
Jubjub
Sat Sep 26 2009 02:22
I don't think your point is well supported. The anime that is shown in Japan differs from the ones in America. There's a huge amount of anime that never even reached the US. And those anime are actually really good. Don't judge a huge group of anime by using an anime like Pokemon or Dragonball Z to rate them all. Some good anime that is shown in America were some Hayao Miyazaki movies, Neon Genesis Evangelion. An educational channel even picked apart Evangelion to find out all the hidden meanings. It was also ranked one of the best anime

Pokemon, Dragonball Z and Yugioh aren't really the best anime. Some anime that do really well in America, don't do as well in Japan, and vice versa. Those anime that were brought to America were mostly brought because it was associated with well selling merchandise. Not for their storyline. That's why the animations are lacking in so much. There are plenty of other anime with great storyline.

I don't mind if you hate anime, but I don't like how unsupported your arguement is, or how biased it is. I just find it disturbing that you want to keep kids away from shows that actually teach them something. Why would you want kids to drop out of school, or watch mindless shows?

America has some mindless shows, but you obviously haven't watched from enough channels. I mean haven't you heard of Animal Planet, Discovery, Food Network, TLC and so many others?? Again you're using a small group to judge a huge population. You've been on VH1 too much haven't you? Go switch to another channel for once.

aura
Mon Sep 7 2009 06:40
I laugh at people such as yourself Elon Glucklich. It is people like you who cause conflict and hate. I know plenty of religious anime fans who are still strong in their faith and like anime. Theres a difference between obsession and being an anime fan.

Western cartoons teach nothing more or less then anime does. Cartoons are to entertain not educate. Parents who do not like it don't allow their children to watch it simple as. Educational programs are there to educate, let cartoons and anime be what they are, fun and entertaining, an escape from the the world if only just for a short while.

The downfall of man kind is down to the way we as humans judge, treat and conflict against each other. Not many people teach acceptance to their children anymore. People such as yourself aid this, well done, Elon Glucklich well done.

aura
Mon Sep 7 2009 06:39
I laugh at people such as yourself Elon Glucklich. It is people like you who cause conflict and hate. I know plenty of religious anime fans who are still strong in their faith and like anime. Theres a difference between obsession and being an anime fan.

Western cartoons teach nothing more or less then anime does. Cartoons are to entertain not educate. Parents who do not like it don't allow their children to watch it simple as. Educational programs are there to educate, let cartoons and anime be what they are, fun and entertaining, an escape from the the world if only just for a short while.

The downfall of man kind is down to the way we as humans judge, treat and conflict against each other. Not many people teach acceptance to their children anymore. People such as yourself aid this, well done, Elon Glucklich well done.

Emerald Tiara
Sun Aug 30 2009 17:02
Actually, the Pokemon episode in question had the effects mentioned because one sequence involved lights flashing too fast-- you know how they have to post warnings whenever anyone uses strobe lights? The episode was immediately banned from ever being broadcast again, and I believe it was never shown in America in the first place--please explain how an isolated incident in Japan is destroying America.
I feel like also mentioning that you seem to be mainly sticking to using three shows to represent an entire genre as scapegoats for an imaginary problem. Your article doesn't seem to inspire much support for your ideas, so I suggest you brush up your knowledge a bit if you want to start making any valid points. I also feel like pointing out that the main revolving themes in Yu-Gi-Oh are friendship,compassion and forgiveness-- truly these values will bring naught but destruction and anarchy.
Simply put, your reasoning is off and you've done little, if anything, to prove your points. I admit that my own status as an anime fan might cause me to be biased, but as an intelligent high school junior whose educational future and success are being doubted, I'm entitled to a little bias and also the right to be insulted. YOU don't seem to be holding back your prejudice.
If you seriously stop to think about Tommy everyday, I fear for your stability.






log out